Tom and Harry at the Coffee Shop: High vs. Low Deductibles

Tom: Harry, I don’t understand why you’re still sticking with that low deductible. It’s like paying extra for nothing. I’d rather keep more of my money, thank you very much.

Harry: Oh, sure, Tom, just keep tempting fate. You’re betting on never having a claim. I prefer to sleep well at night, knowing if something happens, I’m not dropping half my savings to fix it.

Tom: Yeah, but that’s the thing—you’re paying that insurance company monthly just for that peace of mind. I mean, think about it. With a higher deductible, my premium is way lower. I’m saving money every month. Plus, it’s not like I’m planning to have an accident.

Harry: Right, because we all plan our accidents. I get it, you’re Mr. Optimistic. But what if your car ends up wrapped around a pole one day? What happens then, huh?

Tom: That’s when my secret weapon comes in—an emergency fund, Harry. I’ve got some cash set aside, just in case. So, if something does happen, I’m ready for it. Until then, I’m not handing over my hard-earned money for no reason.

Harry: Emergency fund, huh? It must be nice—some of us would rather avoid wiping out our savings. Besides, it’s not just about cars. What if your house floods or something?

Tom: Oh, come on, my house is up on a hill! The only flooding we’re dealing with is when my kids leave the garden hose running. But I get your point. Look, it’s not like I’m against coverage—I think having a higher deductible is a smarter way to save. Over time, the difference in premiums adds up. And it’s not like I’m flying blind—I talked to my insurance agent about it. They helped me figure out what made sense based on my finances.

Harry: Yeah, yeah, I talked to my agent too. They actually told me a higher deductible can make sense—if you’ve got the resources to cover it when things go sideways. But personally, I’m not taking any chances. I’d rather keep my deductible low and my stress even lower.

Tom: And that’s fair, Harry. At the end of the day, it’s all about what you’re comfortable with and what you can afford. That’s why talking to an agent is so important—they’re the ones who can help you weigh it all out.

Harry: I’ll give you that one, Tom. It’s like a choose-your-own-adventure book—you just have to know which chapter makes the most sense.

Tom: Exactly! So whether you’re the risk-averse type like Harry or a risk-tolerant maverick like me, the right place to start is with your agent. They’ll help you decide whether high or low deductibles are right. It’s all about finding that balance.

Harry: And, of course, figuring out which one of us gets to buy the other a coffee with all that “savings.”

Tom: Ha! Now that’s a deductible I’m willing to pay.